Musique illimitée
Écoutez cet album en haute-qualité dès maintenant dans nos applications
Démarrer ma période d'essai et lancer l'écoute de cet albumProfitez de cet album sur les apps Qobuz grâce à votre abonnement
SouscrireProfitez de cet album sur les apps Qobuz grâce à votre abonnement
Téléchargement digital
Téléchargez cet album dans la qualité de votre choix
Une version à petit effectif, choral comme instrumental puisqu’il est seulement constitué de 9 chanteurs (dont les solistes), une douzaine de cordes, des bois par deux, ainsi que orgue, clavecin, théorbe mais surtout un contrebasson qui vient rehausser la palette sonore. L’interprétation déçoit autant qu’elle peut captiver. On commence par applaudir à la précision de l’exécution. Dès la saisissante marche de l’ouverture de l’œuvre, pour prendre un exemple, l’oreille est captée par la caractérisation de la formation orchestrale lorsque Minkowski souligne avec pertinence le martèlement des basses comme pour mieux annoncer le calvaire et le supplice du Christ tandis que les violons égrènent la longue série des doubles croches. Même les chorals — qui sont avant tout, dans les Passions de Bach, une ponctuation liturgique venant interrompre l’action dramatique pour exprimer la contrition, l'espérance ou la joie du chrétien face au message divin — sont interprétés dans cette même optique dramaturgique : mais celle-ci leur est-elle vraiment nécessaire ? En revanche, la portée spirituelle de la musique de Bach ne se satisfait pas d’une exécution seulement bien maîtrisée et qui en jette. Il y faut un autre souffle, une autre dimension émotionnelle qui soit à la hauteur de la profondeur mystique de la musique. Trop d’extériorisation théâtrale, de tempos rapides ne laissent pas à l'émotion suffisamment de place pour s'exprimer et toucher. On ressent à divers degrés cette absence d'âme chez les chanteurs — que les 9 chantent en chœur ou séparément —, exception faite, dans l'ensemble, pour l’Evangéliste (Lothar Odinius) qui s’immerge avec expressivité dans sa narration biblique, ainsi que Christian Immler (Jésus) et l’alto Delphine Galou dans le fameux « Es ist vollbracht » ; les autres peinent à vivre leur chant avec la gravité qu’impose le texte — particulièrement le contreténor David Hansen qui joue dans un registre plus proche du salon que du divin. Plus intellectuelle qu'habitée, l'interprétation de Marc Minkowski ne les aide pas non plus à y parvenir. © Qobuz (GG)
Plus d'informations
Vous êtes actuellement en train d’écouter des extraits.
Écoutez plus de 100 millions de titres avec votre abonnement illimité.
Écoutez cette playlist et plus de 100 millions de titres avec votre abonnement illimité.
À partir de CHF 14,99/mois
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - David Hansen, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Christian Immler, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lenneke Ruiten, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Ditte Andersen, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Delphine Galou, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra - Valerio Contaldo, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Felix Speer, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - David Hansen, Contralto Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Christian Immler, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lenneke Ruiten, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Ditte Andersen, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Delphine Galou, Contralto Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lothar Odinius, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra - Valerio Contaldo, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Felix Speer, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - David Hansen, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Christian Immler, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lenneke Ruiten, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Ditte Andersen, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Delphine Galou, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra - Valerio Contaldo, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Felix Speer, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - Christian Immler, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lothar Odinius, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - David Hansen, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Christian Immler, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lenneke Ruiten, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Ditte Andersen, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Delphine Galou, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra - Valerio Contaldo, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Felix Speer, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - Lothar Odinius, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - David Hansen, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - Lothar Odinius, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - Ditte Andersen, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - Christian Immler, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Ditte Andersen, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lothar Odinius, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra - Felix Speer, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - David Hansen, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Christian Immler, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lenneke Ruiten, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Ditte Andersen, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Delphine Galou, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra - Valerio Contaldo, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Felix Speer, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - David Hansen, Contralto Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Christian Immler, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lenneke Ruiten, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Ditte Andersen, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Delphine Galou, Contralto Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lothar Odinius, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra - Valerio Contaldo, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Felix Speer, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - Lothar Odinius, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - David Hansen, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Christian Immler, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lenneke Ruiten, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Ditte Andersen, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Delphine Galou, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra - Valerio Contaldo, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Felix Speer, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - David Hansen, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Christian Immler, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lenneke Ruiten, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Ditte Andersen, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Delphine Galou, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra - Valerio Contaldo, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Felix Speer, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra - Valerio Contaldo, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - David Hansen, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Christian Immler, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lenneke Ruiten, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Ditte Andersen, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Delphine Galou, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra - Valerio Contaldo, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Felix Speer, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - David Hansen, Contralto Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Christian Immler, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lenneke Ruiten, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Ditte Andersen, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Delphine Galou, Contralto Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lothar Odinius, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra - Valerio Contaldo, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Felix Speer, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - David Hansen, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Christian Immler, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lenneke Ruiten, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Ditte Andersen, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Delphine Galou, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra - Valerio Contaldo, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Felix Speer, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - David Hansen, Contralto Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Christian Immler, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lenneke Ruiten, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Ditte Andersen, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Delphine Galou, Contralto Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lothar Odinius, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra - Valerio Contaldo, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Felix Speer, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra - Felix Speer, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - David Hansen, Contralto Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Christian Immler, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lenneke Ruiten, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Ditte Andersen, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Delphine Galou, Contralto Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lothar Odinius, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra - Valerio Contaldo, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Felix Speer, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - David Hansen, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Christian Immler, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lenneke Ruiten, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Ditte Andersen, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Delphine Galou, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra - Valerio Contaldo, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Felix Speer, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - David Hansen, Contralto Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Christian Immler, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lenneke Ruiten, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Ditte Andersen, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Delphine Galou, Contralto Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lothar Odinius, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra - Valerio Contaldo, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Felix Speer, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - David Hansen, Contralto Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Christian Immler, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lenneke Ruiten, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Ditte Andersen, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Delphine Galou, Contralto Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lothar Odinius, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra - Valerio Contaldo, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Felix Speer, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - David Hansen, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Christian Immler, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lenneke Ruiten, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Ditte Andersen, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Delphine Galou, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra - Valerio Contaldo, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Felix Speer, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - David Hansen, Contralto Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Christian Immler, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lenneke Ruiten, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Ditte Andersen, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Delphine Galou, Contralto Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lothar Odinius, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra - Valerio Contaldo, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Felix Speer, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - David Hansen, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Christian Immler, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lenneke Ruiten, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Ditte Andersen, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Delphine Galou, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra - Valerio Contaldo, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Felix Speer, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - Christian Immler, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lothar Odinius, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - Delphine Galou, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - Lothar Odinius, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - David Hansen, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Christian Immler, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lenneke Ruiten, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Ditte Andersen, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Delphine Galou, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra - Valerio Contaldo, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Felix Speer, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - Lothar Odinius, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - Lenneke Ruiten, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - Lothar Odinius, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - David Hansen, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Christian Immler, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lenneke Ruiten, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Ditte Andersen, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Delphine Galou, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra - Valerio Contaldo, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Felix Speer, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - Lothar Odinius, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - David Hansen, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Christian Immler, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lenneke Ruiten, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Ditte Andersen, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Delphine Galou, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra - Valerio Contaldo, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Felix Speer, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer - Marc Minkowski, Conductor, MainArtist - David Hansen, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Christian Immler, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Lenneke Ruiten, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Colin Balzer, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Ditte Andersen, Soprano Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Delphine Galou, Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Les Musiciens du Louvre Grenoble, Orchestra - Valerio Contaldo, Tenor Vocals, FeaturedArtist - Felix Speer, Bass Vocals, FeaturedArtist
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Les Musiciens du Louvre under exclusive licence to Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Chronique
Une version à petit effectif, choral comme instrumental puisqu’il est seulement constitué de 9 chanteurs (dont les solistes), une douzaine de cordes, des bois par deux, ainsi que orgue, clavecin, théorbe mais surtout un contrebasson qui vient rehausser la palette sonore. L’interprétation déçoit autant qu’elle peut captiver. On commence par applaudir à la précision de l’exécution. Dès la saisissante marche de l’ouverture de l’œuvre, pour prendre un exemple, l’oreille est captée par la caractérisation de la formation orchestrale lorsque Minkowski souligne avec pertinence le martèlement des basses comme pour mieux annoncer le calvaire et le supplice du Christ tandis que les violons égrènent la longue série des doubles croches. Même les chorals — qui sont avant tout, dans les Passions de Bach, une ponctuation liturgique venant interrompre l’action dramatique pour exprimer la contrition, l'espérance ou la joie du chrétien face au message divin — sont interprétés dans cette même optique dramaturgique : mais celle-ci leur est-elle vraiment nécessaire ? En revanche, la portée spirituelle de la musique de Bach ne se satisfait pas d’une exécution seulement bien maîtrisée et qui en jette. Il y faut un autre souffle, une autre dimension émotionnelle qui soit à la hauteur de la profondeur mystique de la musique. Trop d’extériorisation théâtrale, de tempos rapides ne laissent pas à l'émotion suffisamment de place pour s'exprimer et toucher. On ressent à divers degrés cette absence d'âme chez les chanteurs — que les 9 chantent en chœur ou séparément —, exception faite, dans l'ensemble, pour l’Evangéliste (Lothar Odinius) qui s’immerge avec expressivité dans sa narration biblique, ainsi que Christian Immler (Jésus) et l’alto Delphine Galou dans le fameux « Es ist vollbracht » ; les autres peinent à vivre leur chant avec la gravité qu’impose le texte — particulièrement le contreténor David Hansen qui joue dans un registre plus proche du salon que du divin. Plus intellectuelle qu'habitée, l'interprétation de Marc Minkowski ne les aide pas non plus à y parvenir. © Qobuz (GG)
À propos
- 1 disque(s) - 42 piste(s)
- Durée totale : 01:50:37
- 1 Livret Numérique
- Artistes principaux : Marc Minkowski
- Compositeur : Johann Sebastian Bach
- Label : Erato - Warner Classics
- Genre : Classique
© 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company ℗ 2017 Parlophone Records Limited, a Warner Music Group Company
Distinctions :
Améliorer les informations de l'albumPourquoi acheter sur Qobuz ?
-
Streamez ou téléchargez votre musique
Achetez un album ou une piste à l’unité. Ou écoutez tout notre catalogue en illimité avec nos abonnements de streaming en haute qualité.
-
Zéro DRM
Les fichiers téléchargés vous appartiennent, sans aucune limite d’utilisation. Vous pouvez les télécharger autant de fois que vous souhaitez.
-
Choisissez le format qui vous convient
Vous disposez d’un large choix de formats pour télécharger vos achats (FLAC, ALAC, WAV, AIFF...) en fonction de vos besoins.
-
Écoutez vos achats dans nos applications
Téléchargez les applications Qobuz pour smartphones, tablettes et ordinateurs, et écoutez vos achats partout avec vous.