Unlimited Streaming
Listen to this album in high quality now on our apps
Start my trial period and start listening to this albumEnjoy this album on Qobuz apps with your subscription
SubscribeEnjoy this album on Qobuz apps with your subscription
Digital Download
Purchase and download this album in a wide variety of formats depending on your needs.
One of the reasons the Melvins remain vital and productive as they approach 40 years as a band is they've never been afraid to try new things and give themselves fresh challenges. However, after a certain point, one begins to run short on new things to try, and their desire to push themselves out of their comfort zone sometimes takes them down blind alleys. This is the case with 2021's Five Legged Dog, which marks the first time the band, known for their crushing volume and downtuned heaviness, has recorded a full-length acoustic album. Perhaps thinking that wasn't novel enough in itself, they have has also made it an epic-scale career overview, featuring new interpretations of tunes from their catalog, as well as a handful of covers, in a marathon production that clocks in at two-and-a-half hours. For a group that's traded so heavily in volume throughout their career, Five Legged Dog finds the Melvins sounding game and committed to this experiment, and guitarist Buzz Osborne, bassist Steven McDonald, and drummer Dale Crover seem especially happy to try out vocal harmonies that would normally get lost over the sound of the overdriven amps and piledriver percussion. The details of McDonald's basslines and Crover's drumming are naturally a lot more clear in this context, and their playing reveals a welcome nuance, showing off sides of their music that they can't normally put into focus. However, while Osborne is a talented guitarist, he's not as interesting on acoustic player as he is on electric, and the textures and dynamics that are second nature in his usual performances are absent here. The simpler, low-volume arrangements also make it pretty clear that these songs were never meant to be heard in this fashion, and they haven't been able to recast them in an acoustic form that gives them force enough to compensate for the lack of volume and punch. The final nail in Five Legged Dog's coffin is its length: 35 or 40 minutes of this music might work as an experiment, but 150 minutes is numbing, especially given the lack of straightforward melodic hooks in the Melvins' songbook. The covers of numbers like the Turtles' "Outside Chance," the Rolling Stones' "Sway," and Fred Neil's "Everybody's Talking" end up being standouts because their relative simplicity, melodicism, and concision are reinforced by the acoustic trio treatment, while the sprawl of the Melvins originals only muddies the waters performed in this format. It's honestly admirable that the Melvins were willing to take a big risk with an album like Five Legged Dog, but the finished product fails more than it succeeds.
© Mark Deming /TiVo
You are currently listening to samples.
Listen to over 100 million songs with an unlimited streaming plan.
Listen to this playlist and more than 100 million songs with our unlimited streaming plans.
From kr133,33/month
Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Jeff McDonald, Composer - Steven McDonald, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
ANDY FRASER, Composer - Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer - Paul Rodgers, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Warren Zevon, Composer - Melvins, MainArtist
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Dale Crover, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Michael Bruce, Composer - Glen Buxton, Composer - Dennis Dunaway, Composer - Neal Smith, Composer - Alice Cooper, Composer - Melvins, MainArtist
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
KEITH RICHARDS, Composer - MICK JAGGER, Composer - Melvins, MainArtist
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Tim Taylor, Composer - Melvins, MainArtist - John Schmersal, Composer - Michelle Bodine, Composer - Juan Monasterio, Composer - Tyler Trent, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Fred Neil, Composer - Melvins, MainArtist
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Mark Deutrom, Composer - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Roger Osborne, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Melvins, MainArtist - Jeff Pinkus, Composer
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Album review
One of the reasons the Melvins remain vital and productive as they approach 40 years as a band is they've never been afraid to try new things and give themselves fresh challenges. However, after a certain point, one begins to run short on new things to try, and their desire to push themselves out of their comfort zone sometimes takes them down blind alleys. This is the case with 2021's Five Legged Dog, which marks the first time the band, known for their crushing volume and downtuned heaviness, has recorded a full-length acoustic album. Perhaps thinking that wasn't novel enough in itself, they have has also made it an epic-scale career overview, featuring new interpretations of tunes from their catalog, as well as a handful of covers, in a marathon production that clocks in at two-and-a-half hours. For a group that's traded so heavily in volume throughout their career, Five Legged Dog finds the Melvins sounding game and committed to this experiment, and guitarist Buzz Osborne, bassist Steven McDonald, and drummer Dale Crover seem especially happy to try out vocal harmonies that would normally get lost over the sound of the overdriven amps and piledriver percussion. The details of McDonald's basslines and Crover's drumming are naturally a lot more clear in this context, and their playing reveals a welcome nuance, showing off sides of their music that they can't normally put into focus. However, while Osborne is a talented guitarist, he's not as interesting on acoustic player as he is on electric, and the textures and dynamics that are second nature in his usual performances are absent here. The simpler, low-volume arrangements also make it pretty clear that these songs were never meant to be heard in this fashion, and they haven't been able to recast them in an acoustic form that gives them force enough to compensate for the lack of volume and punch. The final nail in Five Legged Dog's coffin is its length: 35 or 40 minutes of this music might work as an experiment, but 150 minutes is numbing, especially given the lack of straightforward melodic hooks in the Melvins' songbook. The covers of numbers like the Turtles' "Outside Chance," the Rolling Stones' "Sway," and Fred Neil's "Everybody's Talking" end up being standouts because their relative simplicity, melodicism, and concision are reinforced by the acoustic trio treatment, while the sprawl of the Melvins originals only muddies the waters performed in this format. It's honestly admirable that the Melvins were willing to take a big risk with an album like Five Legged Dog, but the finished product fails more than it succeeds.
© Mark Deming /TiVo
About the album
- 1 disc(s) - 36 track(s)
- Total length: 02:29:33
- Main artists: Melvins
- Composer: Various Composers
- Label: Ipecac Recordings
- Genre: Pop/Rock Rock
2021 Ipecac Recordings 2021 Ipecac Recordings
Improve album informationWhy buy on Qobuz...
-
Stream or download your music
Buy an album or an individual track. Or listen to our entire catalogue with our high-quality unlimited streaming subscriptions.
-
Zero DRM
The downloaded files belong to you, without any usage limit. You can download them as many times as you like.
-
Choose the format best suited for you
Download your purchases in a wide variety of formats (FLAC, ALAC, WAV, AIFF...) depending on your needs.
-
Listen to your purchases on our apps
Download the Qobuz apps for smartphones, tablets and computers, and listen to your purchases wherever you go.