Unlimited Streaming
Listen to this album in high quality now on our apps
Start my trial period and start listening to this albumEnjoy this album on Qobuz apps with your subscription
SubscribeEnjoy this album on Qobuz apps with your subscription
Digital Download
Purchase and download this album in a wide variety of formats depending on your needs.
Perhaps Elvis Costello is so accustomed to preparing a disc of rare material as a supplement to his albums, he couldn't resist assembling a collection of arcania for his 2002 album When I Was Cruel with a second disc a mere six months after its release, so it could stand alongside the exhaustive Rhino reissues of his catalog. Perhaps he and Island/Universal were finding the quickest way to the end of his contract. Perhaps he actually likes the thing. No matter the reason, there's no excusing Cruel Smile, an ungainly mess of radio performances, remixes, live tracks, outtakes, covers, and sundry B-sides. Sure, this is the kind of thing that would be a boon to hardcore fans...if it were any good, whatsoever. Instead, it's an appalling display of hubris, capturing Costello fooling around in the studio with remixes, grandstanding on stage, tossing off covers, throwing out a couple of unreleased songs, some of which were released as B-sides or overseas singles. It's standard stuff, the kind of thing that fanatics willingly sacrifice meals to hear, to own, but there are no hidden gems here, nothing worth hearing. Instead, it sounds like a parody of the bonus discs on the Expanded Editions that are all the rage in the reissue market in the early years of the 21st century, but it's no joke; it's intended seriously. And perhaps for some completists, just getting this material at a reasonable price is worthwhile. Then again, in a year where Costello product flooded the market, it's much easier to get irritated at its very existence and question whether you really do need a shelf full of Costello material you'll never listen to, particularly if it's as dull and pretentious as this.
© Stephen Thomas Erlewine /TiVo
You are currently listening to samples.
Listen to over 100 million songs with an unlimited streaming plan.
Listen to this playlist and more than 100 million songs with our unlimited streaming plans.
From 12.49€/month
Greg Cohen, Bass Guitar, AssociatedPerformer - KEVIN KILLEN, Producer - Marc Ribot, Guitar, AssociatedPerformer - Charlie Chaplin, ComposerLyricist - John Turner, ComposerLyricist - Geoffrey Parsons, ComposerLyricist - ELVIS COSTELLO, Producer, Orchestra/Member, AssociatedPerformer - Roy Nathanson, Saxophone, AssociatedPerformer - Joey Baron, Drums, AssociatedPerformer - Bill Ware, Vibraphone, AssociatedPerformer - Elvis Costello & The Imposters, MainArtist - Antony Coleman, Piano, AssociatedPerformer
℗ 2002 The Island Def Jam Music Group
ELVIS COSTELLO, ComposerLyricist - Elvis Costello & The Imposters, MainArtist - The Imposters, Producer
℗ 2002 The Island Def Jam Music Group
ELVIS COSTELLO, ComposerLyricist - Elvis Costello & The Imposters, MainArtist - The Imposters, Producer
℗ 2002 The Island Def Jam Music Group
KEVIN KILLEN, Engineer, StudioPersonnel - Pete Thomas, Drums, AssociatedPerformer - Leo Pearson, Unknown, Co-Mixer, Other, StudioPersonnel - Steve Nieve, Organ, AssociatedPerformer - ELVIS COSTELLO, Mixer, Electric Guitar, Unknown, Other, AssociatedPerformer, StudioPersonnel, ComposerLyricist - Ciaran Cahill, Recording Engineer, Co-Mixer, StudioPersonnel - Roy Nathanson, Saxophone, AssociatedPerformer - Kieran Lynch, Asst. Recording Engineer, Co-Mixer, StudioPersonnel - Jay Rodriguez, Saxophone, AssociatedPerformer - Elvis Costello & The Imposters, MainArtist - The Imposter, Producer - Ku-Umba, Trumpet, AssociatedPerformer - Curtis Foukles, Trombone, AssociatedPerformer
℗ 2002 The Island Def Jam Music Group
KEVIN KILLEN, Engineer, StudioPersonnel - Davey Faragher, Bass Guitar, AssociatedPerformer - Leo Pearson, Unknown, Co-Mixer, Other, StudioPersonnel - ELVIS COSTELLO, Mixer, Electric Guitar, Unknown, Other, AssociatedPerformer, StudioPersonnel, ComposerLyricist - Ciaran Cahill, Recording Engineer, Co-Mixer, StudioPersonnel - Kieran Lynch, Asst. Recording Engineer, Co-Mixer, StudioPersonnel - Elvis Costello & The Imposters, MainArtist - The Imposter, Producer
℗ 2002 The Island Def Jam Music Group
Antonio Amurri, ComposerLyricist - ELVIS COSTELLO, ComposerLyricist - Bruno Canfora, ComposerLyricist - Elvis Costello & The Imposters, MainArtist - The Imposters, Producer, Remixer, StudioPersonnel
℗ 2002 The Island Def Jam Music Group
ELVIS COSTELLO, ComposerLyricist - Elvis Costello & The Imposters, MainArtist - The Imposters, Producer
℗ 2002 The Island Def Jam Music Group
ELVIS COSTELLO, Unknown, Other, ComposerLyricist - Ciaran Cahill, Recording Engineer, StudioPersonnel - Kieran Lynch, Asst. Recording Engineer, StudioPersonnel - Elvis Costello & The Imposters, MainArtist - The Imposter, Producer
℗ 2002 The Island Def Jam Music Group
K. Fareed, ComposerLyricist - KEVIN KILLEN, Engineer, StudioPersonnel - Leo Pearson, Unknown, Co-Mixer, Other, StudioPersonnel - Steve Nieve, Keyboards, AssociatedPerformer - ELVIS COSTELLO, Mixer, Guitar, AssociatedPerformer, StudioPersonnel, ComposerLyricist - Ciaran Cahill, Recording Engineer, Co-Mixer, StudioPersonnel - Kieran Lynch, Asst. Recording Engineer, Co-Mixer, StudioPersonnel - Elvis Costello & The Imposters, MainArtist - The Imposter, Producer
℗ 2002 The Island Def Jam Music Group
ELVIS COSTELLO, ComposerLyricist - Elvis Costello & The Imposters, MainArtist - The Imposters, Producer
℗ 2002 The Island Def Jam Music Group
Richard Rodgers, ComposerLyricist - Lorenz Hart, ComposerLyricist - ELVIS COSTELLO, ComposerLyricist - Elvis Costello & The Imposters, MainArtist - The Imposters, Producer
℗ 2002 The Island Def Jam Music Group
KEVIN KILLEN, Engineer, StudioPersonnel - Pete Thomas, Drums, AssociatedPerformer - Davey Faragher, Bass Guitar, AssociatedPerformer - Leo Pearson, Unknown, Co-Mixer, Other, StudioPersonnel - Steve Nieve, Organ, AssociatedPerformer - ELVIS COSTELLO, Mixer, Guitar, AssociatedPerformer, StudioPersonnel, ComposerLyricist - Ciaran Cahill, Recording Engineer, Co-Mixer, StudioPersonnel - Kieran Lynch, Asst. Recording Engineer, Co-Mixer, StudioPersonnel - Elvis Costello & The Imposters, MainArtist - The Imposter, Producer
℗ 2002 The Island Def Jam Music Group
ELVIS COSTELLO, ComposerLyricist - Elvis Costello & The Imposters, MainArtist - The Imposters, Producer
℗ 2002 The Island Def Jam Music Group
Charlie Chaplin, ComposerLyricist - John Turner, ComposerLyricist - Geoffrey Parsons, ComposerLyricist - Elvis Costello & The Imposters, MainArtist - The Imposters, Producer
℗ 2002 The Island Def Jam Music Group
KEVIN KILLEN, Engineer, StudioPersonnel - Leo Pearson, Unknown, Co-Mixer, Other, StudioPersonnel - Steve Nieve, Vibraphone, AssociatedPerformer - ELVIS COSTELLO, Mixer, Guitar, AssociatedPerformer, StudioPersonnel, ComposerLyricist - Ciaran Cahill, Recording Engineer, Co-Mixer, StudioPersonnel - Kieran Lynch, Asst. Recording Engineer, Co-Mixer, StudioPersonnel - Elvis Costello & The Imposters, MainArtist - The Imposter, Producer
℗ 2002 The Island Def Jam Music Group
Album review
Perhaps Elvis Costello is so accustomed to preparing a disc of rare material as a supplement to his albums, he couldn't resist assembling a collection of arcania for his 2002 album When I Was Cruel with a second disc a mere six months after its release, so it could stand alongside the exhaustive Rhino reissues of his catalog. Perhaps he and Island/Universal were finding the quickest way to the end of his contract. Perhaps he actually likes the thing. No matter the reason, there's no excusing Cruel Smile, an ungainly mess of radio performances, remixes, live tracks, outtakes, covers, and sundry B-sides. Sure, this is the kind of thing that would be a boon to hardcore fans...if it were any good, whatsoever. Instead, it's an appalling display of hubris, capturing Costello fooling around in the studio with remixes, grandstanding on stage, tossing off covers, throwing out a couple of unreleased songs, some of which were released as B-sides or overseas singles. It's standard stuff, the kind of thing that fanatics willingly sacrifice meals to hear, to own, but there are no hidden gems here, nothing worth hearing. Instead, it sounds like a parody of the bonus discs on the Expanded Editions that are all the rage in the reissue market in the early years of the 21st century, but it's no joke; it's intended seriously. And perhaps for some completists, just getting this material at a reasonable price is worthwhile. Then again, in a year where Costello product flooded the market, it's much easier to get irritated at its very existence and question whether you really do need a shelf full of Costello material you'll never listen to, particularly if it's as dull and pretentious as this.
© Stephen Thomas Erlewine /TiVo
About the album
- 1 disc(s) - 15 track(s)
- Total length: 01:10:54
- Main artists: Elvis Costello
- Composer: Various Composers
- Label: Island Def Jam
- Genre: Pop/Rock Rock
© 2002 The Island Def Jam Music Group ℗ 2002 The Island Def Jam Music Group
Improve album information
Why buy on Qobuz...
-
Stream or download your music
Buy an album or an individual track. Or listen to our entire catalogue with our high-quality unlimited streaming subscriptions.
-
Zero DRM
The downloaded files belong to you, without any usage limit. You can download them as many times as you like.
-
Choose the format best suited for you
Download your purchases in a wide variety of formats (FLAC, ALAC, WAV, AIFF...) depending on your needs.
-
Listen to your purchases on our apps
Download the Qobuz apps for smartphones, tablets and computers, and listen to your purchases wherever you go.